An article from the New York Times from January 5, 2012 has been hotly debated in the yoga community. It’s called “How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body” by William J. Broad, and it describes injuries from yoga practice to the lower back, shoulders, knees, neck, and ribs, and even hip replacements and strokes believed to be due to yoga.
The teacher mentioned in the article, Glenn Black, attracted clients with yoga injuries to his bodywork and yoga classes. He didn’t teach any inversions (such as headstand or shoulderstand), because he felt they were dangerous. Black says that “…the vast majority of people should give up yoga altogether. It’s simply too likely to cause harm.” He feels that it’s better to focus on exercises that increase range-of-motion and strengthen weak parts of the body.
What Causes These Injuries?
People come to yoga with their own physical limitations, and in Western culture, we often sit all day and then push ourselves in a strenuous workout or yoga class. The article mentions that in India, many people do different postures throughout their day, such as squatting, which can better prepare them for yoga asanas.
There were no mentions of injuries from yoga in the early books written on yoga in the 20th century, including “Light on Yoga” by B.K.S. Iyengar. Since then yoga has become incredibly popular, with a 5-fold increase in yoga practitioners between 2001-2011. There are lots of yoga studios, and not all teachers may have had sufficient training to prevent injuries.
The article also mentions ego-driven teachers who push their students to do more, more, more, which tends to encourage students to push more, and possibly go too far. This is also common in American culture in general, where the urge to compete can be really strong, and can lead people to disregard their own inner guidance and better judgment.
In some yoga poses the head is dropped back, which can be risky. An Oxford neurophysiologist named W. Ritchie Russell found that there was a rare danger of strokes from “excessive extensions of the neck, such as occur in whiplash.” Taking the head and neck into extreme positions “could wound the vertebral arteries, producing clots, swelling and constriction.”
That’s a scary thought! And yoga was supposed to be so good for you! There has been a belief that yoga only has benefits to practitioners, and no dangers. I myself have been injured in yoga classes.
In one teacher training I was in back in 1991 we were to sit for about 45 minutes in Virasana (a pose where your knees are bent, the pelvis is seated on the floor and the feet are on either side of the pelvis) while listening to lectures. My legs would fall asleep repeatedly, and it was hard to get up afterwards. The article mentions a student who did a similar pose for hours daily and developed nerve problems in his legs that made walking difficult.
I also hurt my back doing a deep backbend in another yoga class, and had 2 other injuries, all of which happened when I was being assisted by the teacher or other students in the class to go deeper into the pose. When I was younger, I loved to attend advanced yoga classes, and I would do anything the teacher proposed. You can get away with a lot when you’re in your 20’s that may not work so well a few decades later!
Making Yoga Safer
After I met Jean Couch in 1994, I changed my yoga practice completely. Since Jean had studied with Noelle Perez-Christiaens from Paris, she had given up practicing and teaching advanced yoga poses. Noelle is the author of many books (most are in French), including, “Attention! Le Yoga peut etre dangereux pour vous; pathologie du yoga.” My best translation of this (helped by Google Translate) is “Attention! Yoga can be dangerous to you; pathology of yoga.”
This book was published in 1980, many years before yoga hit the big time. Noelle studied with B.K.S. Iyengar for decades before that, and feels that she ruined her body by doing extreme yoga poses that were better suited for Indians. Urged by Iyengar, she studied posture around the world and discovered that less industrialized cultures had a different and healthier posture than Western industrialized countries. They also had less back pain. Noelle’s and Jean’s work is the basis of my teaching (the Balance Posture Method).
When I began studying with Jean I had to let go of many poses that I practiced regularly, and I started over with doing yoga in a safe way, with a precise focus on alignment of the spine. I have had no yoga injuries since then.
It is essential to respect the limits of your body, to know when to push and when to stop. It can be fine to feel that burn in a muscle when you’re on a long bike ride or hike, or a deep stretch in a yoga asana/pose. But there are also warnings to pay attention to – any sensations of ripping, popping, strain, joint pain, or just a sense that you shouldn’t go any farther. Trust yourself! It’s better to be safe than sorry!
Should You Do Yoga?
So, can yoga wreck your body? If done aggressively, competitively, and without paying attention to your body’s needs – YES. If you do poses where you drop your head back – yes. If you come from a culture like ours where our daily posture is misaligned – yes. But, you can also use yoga to heal from those injuries. I teach classes focused on this and I’ve studied with other teachers who specialize in this as well.
For some tips on how to practice yoga safely, check out these previous blog posts:
http://www.sonomabodybalance.com/blog/2011/02/3-tips-for-a-safe-yoga-practice/
http://www.sonomabodybalance.com/blog/2010/03/how-to-do-yoga-without-back-pain/
Just to counterbalance all that other information, the article in the NY Times also states that “yoga can lower your blood pressure, make chemicals that act as antidepressants, even improve your sex life.” I have experienced many benefits from doing yoga, from increased relaxation to strength and increased flexibility, especially since I’ve changed my way of practicing.
To keep yourself safe and experience the positive side of yoga, find a teacher with training in healthy alignment. Listen to your body. Go slowly at first. And do it for yourself, not to compete with someone else.
By the way, the teacher in the article, Glenn Black, had to have back surgery eventually. He had done enough damage at that point I suppose.
If you learn to have healthy posture in your daily life (see my classes at www.sonomabodybalance.com), you can support the health of your spine and other joints throughout your entire day, every day, not only in a yoga class. And that really can help you prevent injuries, in yoga and anywhere else!
© Dana K. Davis, 2012
